In 2023, Toronto had a pretty interesting mayoral election. Not just because John Tory abruptly resigned after having an affair with a staffer, but also because his successor — Olivia Chow — has won the subsequent election with only 37% of the vote. Though she has been a decent mayor so far, we have no way of definitively knowing that she was really the choice preferred by most Torontonians in a 1v1 matchup against any other candidate.
It’s not hard to find even more extreme outcomes under the first-past-the-post system. Take, for example, this 2021 Canadian federal election result in the electoral district of Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame, where a vote split on the left has definitely produced a winner that the majority of the voters didn’t want:
Party | Candidate | Votes | % |
---|---|---|---|
Conservative | Clifford Small | 14,927 | 46.89% |
Liberal | Scott Simms | 14,646 | 46.00% |
New Democratic | Jamie Ruby | 2,261 | 7.10% |
So how can we make the system more representative?